Year after year, a few Pro Bowl selections either leave me scratching my head or in a fit of rage. Now don't get me wrong; I think the fans get most of the picks right. But there are always some guys that just get left out, whose places are filled by less deserving players. Here's a list of the biggest snubs and undeserving picks in the 2009 Pro Bowl.
NFCQBs
Undeserving pick
Eli Manning (NYG)
OK, we will never forget what he did in 2008 Super Bowl back in February, but that was last season. Eli is having his best season yet, but thats' not saying much for a guy who has been an average quarterback for most of his career. Aside from the Super Bowl victory and his relation to Peyton, I don't see why else he's in the game. Yeah his team has a great record, but that's primarily due to the defense, the offensive line (considered by some to be the bets in football) and running game (the Giants lead the NFL in rushing). If we're gonna put Eli in the game, we might as well get Kerry Collins in there too.
Snub
Tony Romo (DAL)
Despite missing three games this season, Romo has throw for more yards than Eli, thrown more touchdownss and his passer rating is 13 points higher. And unlike Eli, Romo is the engine that makes the Dallas Cowboys go. He has the better fantasy numbers and is more valuable to his team.
RBs
Undeserving pick
Clinton Portis (WAS)
Yes, he is third in the NFC in rushing, and he led the Redskins to good start, keyword being led. After an impressive start, the Redskins have trailed off into mediocrity. Portis is having a pretty decent season; but due to his past success, he has overshadowed a more deserving candidate.
Snub
DeAngelo Williams (CAR)
Williams has broke out in his 3rd NFL season, lead the Carolina Panthers to an 11-3 record. He has about 100 fewer yards rushing than Portis, but is far more efficient. He averages about 10 more yards per game, has twice as many TDs and hasn't fumbled the ball once all season.
WRs
Undeserving pick
Anquan Boldin (ARI)
Boldin has had a great season, so it's hard for me to say he's undeserving. But the fact remains that he is the number two option in Arizona. Besides, I can think of another guy who should get that spot.
Snub
Calvin Johnson (DET)
Forget the fact that the Lions are 0-14. That team is so awful, they probably couldn't win a game with Jerry Rice in his prime. In just his second season, Calvin Johnson has emerged as one of the premiere wide receivers in the NFL, and unlike Boldin, who is catching passes from Kurt Warner, Johnson is reeling in catches from the likes of John Kitna (who went out early in the season), Dan Orlovsky (that idiot who ran out of the end zone for a safety), and Daunte Culpepper (a shadow of his former self). Despite all of this, Johnson has roughly 150 more receiving yards and just one less TD. He is also vastly more explosive than Boldin, with 19 catches of 20+ yards (Boldin has just 10) and 7 catches of 40+ yards (Boldin only has 3). Both are great players, but I'll take the true franchise wide receiver over the guy getting spoon fed by the man who will probably be named the 2008 NFL MVP.
DTs
Undeserving picks
Kevin Williams and Pat Williams (MIN)
Earlier this year, the two defensive tackles for the Minnesota Vikings tested positive for a banned diarrhetic, believed to be a masking agent for steroids. I know they are great players, but they broke the rules and don't deserve the honor of competing in a game that is supposed to represent the very best the NFL has to offer.
Snubs
Rocky Bernard (SEA)
He is second only to Kevin Williams in tackles at his position AND he hasn't tested positive for a banned substance. Bernard also has four sacks along with a forced fumble and fumble recovery.
Mr. X (pick your team)
Honestly, there are a bunch of defensive tackles in the NFC with roughly the same statistics, so the difference between them is negligible. Bottom line; any player who has played the game the right way is getting slapped in the face by the selections of Kevin Williams and Pat Williams.
AFCQBs
Undeserving pick
Brett Favre (NYJ)
Favre is one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time. That said, he is not currently one of the top three quarterbacks in the AFC. The only reason why he is in the Pro Bowl this year is because of his past success in Green Bay and all the media scrutiny he's received since being traded to the Jets. Oh, being on the cover of Madden NFL 09 didn't hurt either. The fact that six other Jets were named to the Pro Bowl is a clear indication that he is not the sole reason for their success this year.
Snub
Philip Rivers (SD)
Yet another quarterback who leads his conference in passer rating was snubbed by a New York quarterback. Rivers is far more deserving than Farve; he trounces him in nearly every passing category. He has thrown for 500 more yards, seven more touchdowns, and has thrown six fewer interceptions. Just as Favre isn't responsible for the Jets' success, Rivers can't be blamed for the Chargers' failure.
RBs
Undeserving pick
Ronnie Brown (MIA)
He has less than 1,000 yards on the ground for the season, less than 60 yards per game, only 4.2 yards per carry, and four of his 10 touchdowns came in one game. It is great to see Brown back healthy and playing well, but he simply is not good enough to play in the Pro Bowl.
Snub
Steve Slaton (HOU)
Chris Johnson wasn't the only great running back in this year's NFL draft. Slaton has rushed for over 1,100 yards at just under five yards per carry. He has two fewer touchdowns than Brown, but is averaging 20 more yards per game. He also has 100 more receiving yards than Brown as well as a touchdown catch. Without him, the Texans wouldn't be anywhere close to 7-7.
TEs
Undeserving Pick
Antonio Gates (SD)
Much like teammate LaDainian Tomlinson, Antonio Gates is on pace to have his worst season since his rookie year. LT has taken the fall for the Chargers and was not selected to the Pro Bowl, but Gates remains one of the NFL's top tight ends. He is still the most talented tight end in the NFL; he just hasn't performed as well as some of the other tight ends in the AFC this year.
Snub
Dallas Clark (IND)
He is putting up better statistics than Gates and his team is performing better, which basically adds up to him being more deserving of a Pro Bowl selection. He has 10 more receptions, 60 more yards receiving and just one less touchdown.